The Evolution of Internal Audit: Confronting Challenges in a Complex Landscape

Over the past few decades, the role of internal audit has evolved significantly from its early, manual processes to a more digital and data-driven function. Despite these advancements, internal audit often struggles to gain the full respect and stature it deserves within organizations. Several persistent challenges continue to impede the profession’s growth and impact.

Persistent Challenges in Internal Audit

1. Perceived Importance: Many organizational leaders still view internal audit as less critical than other functions, often relegating it to a “necessary evil” rather than a strategic partner. This perception limits the effectiveness and influence of audit teams, particularly in obtaining necessary resources or gaining a seat at the executive table.
2. Risk-Based Approach: While the profession has emphasized the importance of a risk-based audit plan, many internal audit departments still fail to align their focus with the key strategic risks faced by their organizations. Instead, they often rely on bottom-up risk assessments that may not reflect the true priorities of senior leadership.
3. Standards vs. Quality: Adherence to internal audit standards, such as those established by the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), does not always translate to high-quality audits. Internal audit departments can follow these standards without necessarily adding significant value to their organizations. The emphasis on compliance with standards over practical impact can lead to a disconnect between audit activities and organizational needs.
4. External Auditor Perception: External auditors often do not see internal audit as a valuable resource, sometimes using internal teams to perform routine tasks that do not utilize their full capabilities. This can lead to frustration and a sense of underutilization within internal audit departments.
5. Competency Gaps: As organizations become more complex, internal audit departments often lack the diverse skills needed to effectively execute a modern, risk-based audit plan. Training and upskilling initiatives can help, but resource constraints and limited budgets frequently pose barriers to these efforts.
6. Underutilization of Co-Sourcing: Many internal audit teams do not leverage co-sourcing partnerships effectively. While co-sourcing can fill competency gaps, finding reliable partners and managing these relationships remains a challenge. Poorly managed co-sourcing projects can result in suboptimal outcomes and wasted resources.
7. Accounting Stereotype: Despite significant advancements in the field, internal audit is still often viewed as an extension of accounting rather than a multifaceted function that addresses a broad spectrum of organizational risks. This outdated perception limits the profession’s ability to attract talent with diverse backgrounds and skills.
8. Technology Adoption: Many internal audit functions are not adopting advanced technologies quickly enough. Without sufficient investment in data analytics, automation, and other technologies, internal audit departments risk falling behind and becoming less effective in their roles.

Strategies for Overcoming Challenges

Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach:

• Enhancing Perceived Value: Internal audit must demonstrate its strategic value by aligning its focus with the organization’s top risks and providing actionable insights that support business objectives.
• Improving Risk Alignment: Developing a more top-down approach to risk assessment, guided by senior leadership’s perspectives, can help internal audit better prioritize its activities and add greater value.
• Balancing Standards and Impact: While adherence to standards is important, internal audit must also focus on the practical impact of its work. This means engaging with stakeholders to understand their needs and delivering audits that directly support organizational goals.
• Building Competency: Investing in training and co-sourcing can help internal audit acquire the skills necessary to tackle emerging risks. Strategic partnerships with external experts can provide short-term support while internal capabilities are developed.
• Leveraging Technology: Embracing advanced technologies like data analytics, robotic process automation, and AI can enhance audit efficiency and effectiveness. By adopting these tools, internal audit can shift its focus from routine tasks to high-value activities that require critical thinking and professional judgment.

Conclusion

The internal audit profession is at a crossroads. To continue its evolution and meet the complex demands of modern organizations, it must address these uncomfortable truths head-on. By aligning its activities with strategic priorities, enhancing its skill set, and leveraging technology, internal audit can reposition itself as an indispensable component of corporate governance. This transformation will not only elevate the profession’s stature but also enable internal audit to make a meaningful impact on organizational success.

Internal audit is a tough profession, and often thankless. Make it easier to do your job by automating your workflows, adding persistent scheduling, and tracking issues along the way with Connected Risk’s Internal Audit Management. Learn more about Internal Audit Management here and set up a demonstration to speak to a solutions expert today.