When risk models fail, banks can lose a lot of money. This was the case in both the 2012 London Whale Trading Incident and the 2008 Great Financial Crisis. In both cases, a lack of proper governance led to serious losses for financial institutions due to errors in their credit models. Let’s take a closer look at these two incidents and what they can teach us about the importance of proper risk model governance.
The London Whale Trading Incident
In 2012, JPMorgan Chase lost over $6 billion due to an error in their credit model that had gone unchecked. This incident is now known as the “London Whale” trading incident because it involved traders in London making trades that were not properly monitored or regulated. A lack of oversight and proper governance allowed for these trades to go through without being properly reviewed or flagged, resulting in major losses for JPMorgan Chase.
This incident highlights how important it is for banks to have effective governance structures in place when using risk models. It also shows why it is essential for banks to invest in strong compliance programs and model risk management practices so that any errors or irregularities can be detected quickly and addressed appropriately.
What Happened?
The London Whale trading incident occurred when JPMorgan Chase’s CIO in London, led by Bruno Iksil, made an ill-fated bet on credit default swaps (CDS). This bet went wrong and resulted in $6 billion in losses for the company. This incident has become one of the most well-known examples of financial mismanagement and regulatory failure.
How Could It Have Been Avoided?
This incident could have been avoided if JPMorgan had implemented proper model risk management procedures. Model risk management is important because it ensures that all models used by financial organizations are accurate and reliable. If JPMorgan had implemented proper model risk management procedures, they would have been able to detect any errors or inaccuracies in their models before making any trades. This would have enabled them to avoid such significant losses due to modeling errors or misjudgments. Additionally, they could have also identified any potential conflicts of interest or areas of regulatory non-compliance early on.
Why Is Model Risk Management Important?
Model risk management is critical for any financial organization as it helps ensure accuracy and reliability in all models used by the organization. Poorly managed models can lead to inaccurate results which can cost organizations significant amounts of money if not properly managed. Furthermore, model risk management also helps organizations identify potential conflicts of interest or areas of regulatory non-compliance early on which can help them avoid costly fines or other penalties later down the line. Finally, effective model risk management also helps build trust with customers as it shows that your organization takes its responsibilities seriously and is taking steps to ensure accuracy and reliability in all its operations.
The London Whale trading incident highlights just how important model risk management is for any financial organization as it can help prevent costly mistakes from occurring due to modeling errors or misjudgments. By implementing effective model risk management processes, organizations can ensure accuracy and reliability in all their models while also identifying potential conflicts of interest or areas of regulatory non-compliance before they become major issues down the line. Model risk managers should take this incident as an example of what could happen if proper processes are not put into place—and strive to create a system that will help prevent such incidents from happening again in the future.
The 2008 Great Financial Crisis
The 2008 Great Financial Crisis was another example of how banks can suffer huge losses as a result of inadequate governance structures around their credit models. During this crisis, many banks were using overly simplistic copula models to estimate the risks associated with mortgage portfolios—a practice that did not account for all potential risks associated with investing in mortgages. As a result, many banks suffered massive losses during this time period as they failed to adequately assess their exposure to risk when investing in mortgage-backed securities.
The crisis was caused by a number of factors, but one of the key elements was model risk management – or, more specifically, the lack thereof. By not properly managing the risks associated with their investment models, many banks were exposed to significant losses when the markets turned south.
How Proper Model Risk Management Could Have Mitigated the Crisis
In 2008, many banks did not have adequate MRM processes in place to properly assess the risks associated with their investment models. This led to significant losses when markets began to decline due to economic forces such as rising oil prices and subprime mortgage defaults. For example, some banks did not properly understand or account for correlations between different types of investments; this led to unexpected losses when certain investments performed worse than expected due to correlations that had not been accounted for in their models.
Good MRM practices could have helped avert disaster by ensuring that banks had a good understanding of the potential risks associated with their investment models and were taking steps to mitigate those risks accordingly. Banks should have understood correlations between different types of investments and adjusted their models accordingly; they should also have ensured that they were accounting for all potential sources of risk in their models – such as political or economic events that might affect the performance of certain investments – before making any decisions based on those models.
Good model risk management is essential for avoiding costly mistakes when investing or engaging in other financial transactions. The failure of many banks to implement proper MRM processes was a major factor in causing the 2008 financial crisis; if better MRM practices had been employed, much of the damage from this crisis could have been avoided. It’s important for financial institutions today to ensure that they are employing best-in-class MRM practices so that they can avoid similar disasters in the future.
Concluding Thoughts
It is clear from both the London Whale Trading Incident and the 2008 Great Financial Crisis that a lack of effective governance around credit models can lead to significant losses for financial institutions. Banks must ensure that they have strong compliance programs and model risk management practices in place so that any irregularities or errors can be identified quickly and addressed appropriately before they lead to major losses like those seen during these two incidents. By taking steps such as implementing robust oversight mechanisms, conducting regular audits, and providing ongoing training on best practices, banks can ensure their credit models are functioning optimally while reducing their overall exposure to risk.
Looking to manage your Model Risk Management? Check out Connected Risk MRM and book a free demo with one of our solution experts today!
